sometimes sharing the whole truth isn’t easy
I’ve realized over the past few weeks that I’ve come to dread the question: “So, how is Isabel doing?”
While I’m sure that answering with “She’s doing fine” would alleviate the anxst and awkwardness that sometimes follows, it’s neither accurate nor descriptive, nor always honest about the full picture. But the honest answer isn’t always the easiest.
Part of the struggle to answer the question comes from which perspective to provide. I could answer medically, and confuse myself as much as anyone with strange termonology like “She has a variant of hydranencephaly,” instead, I usually talk about how she had a stroke that damaged the tissue in her brain.
(Despite the generally poor prognosis that comes with this condition, it is seemingly miraculous not onlythat Isabel is alive, but that she is so beautiful (not kidding, ie. she has no malformation), that she eats well, and doesn’t show any health concerns. While that doesn’t eliminate the significant challenges she will face, it is certainly amazingly good news.)
Or instead taking about “spastic quadriparesis” or “bilateral optic atrophy & mild hypoplasia,” we try to describe motor skill & muscle tone problems she has that limit her use of her arms or hands, or about what we are learning about her vision and some visual impairment, of which we are not sure the full extent of. Developmentally, all this means that Isabel, despite being almost 10 months old and in the 98th percentile for height & weight (and extreme beauty!!), tests at the development of a 3 or 4 month old baby in several areas. The big question mark remains about how she will respond to all of the therapy.
As such, usually I’ll talk about her treatment routine - the physical therapy she gets twice a week; the stretching exercises we do with her 3 to 4 times a day; getting “tummy time” to activate and strengthen the muscles in her back and neck so that she can hold her head up; or the weekly infant stimulation therapy she just started, which we hope will maximize her visual capacity. (She saw the red light… ask us about what that means.)
Some days all the exercise can be rough for her. But we’ve also begun to see some encouraging signs as her hands are opening up, she’s able to hold her neck up more than before, and she has even begun to lift her hands to her face a few times while she sleeps at night.
Or, speaking of sleep, I can share about how she started being able to take naps on her own in the crib just a few weeks ago. Since she was about 4 months old - and too big to swaddle anymore - she hasn’t been able to nap at all, except in our arms. In addition to her developmental delays, she also has what is known as “Sensory Integration Disorder,” particulary in the area of touch, called “Tactile Defensiveness,” which affects her in how she recieves touch.
What this means is that she needs deep pressure or firm touch in order to relax. As her body was relaxing more through therapy, we started transitioning her to her crip during her naps and have a few other props to give her the pressure sensation that she needs to stay asleep… a big relief for mom & dad.
The funnest part is seeing her wake up from her naps, or in the morning, often giggling or smiling. Well rested, this girl puts cute in another zip code. The problem is, often she wakes up in the middle of the night, unable to put herself back to sleep. When we walk into her room, without even turning the lights on, she starts giggling. Even though we’d love her to just fall right back to sleep, her laugh is a little contagious. Plus, unless or until she is able to develop her arm & hand skills - the ones needed for any self-soothing ie. being able to put her pacifier back into her own mouth - we’ll continue starting her off to sleep in our arms.
I could go on about the bureaucratic battle it has been to get her services through the Regional Center (not my favorite people on earth…). Or about Isabel’s increasingly flirtateous personality - how she loves zerberts & wet smooches & being nosed. Or I could share about - after sharing her story with someone - having to deal with the “but she’s OK, right?” or the “Well, you guys are the perfect parents for her” responses that seem to follow.
I’m not sure I’ve filled out all of Isabel’s story. It all seems to depend on which perspective we choose to share.
If only “She’s just fine” captured it all…

September 22nd, 2006 at 11:29 am
thanks for the posting Scott. Somehow “you guys are the perfect parents” doesn’t really touch the depth of what you guys are going through and what isa is Going through. thanks for taking the time to tell. When I hear about Isa, I so want to be hopeful, and reading the post helps - and since she can’t say “I have the perfect parents” yet, we’ll just keep thinking it for her
October 2nd, 2006 at 1:35 pm
Dear Spanglish,
“just fine”, may not feel right for the life situations your family has to experience, but it does appear perfectly accurate.
It is hard to understand any one’s role in the universe, but rest assured, all roles are critical, and the universe could not be even with the removal of a single cell from its present existence. We are where we have to be, doing exactly what is necessary. This is constant, our degree of suffering is variable.
It is only when we remain within our mental identity that Isabelle appears to lack by judgement. Those with healthy kids may prop their own sense of self by saying, “Look at that poor child, that unlucky couple.” Regardless of judgement, there she is - there is Isabelle for your awareness, and for her self-awareness as well. May she help to bring the glory of existence to you and all who are touched by her existence. May you enjoy peace.
Jim
October 2nd, 2006 at 3:18 pm
Cam - Thanks for the encouragement. Much appreciated.
Jim - Likewise, I appreciate your empathy. Greatly appreciated. While no one has said “poor child” or “unlucky couple,” I know what you mean.
I must say, though, I’m not quite sure I understand your ethereal lingo about “remaining in our mental identity”, or “the glory of existence.” What I am familiar with is my daughter’s created identity, and the glory of God in all of God’s creation, including God’s creation of my daughter. By her creator, she has truly been “beautifully & wonderfully made.” My prayer is that she would come to know that fully.
There is nothing in her (or our) current suffering that smudges or smears God’s glory, nor anything that detracts from God’s everpresent-ness with us in Jesus. By his presence, we do enjoy great peace.